I find that when comping CG, you have to make the choice between using the light groups OR using diffuse/spec/sss etc
For instance, once you have adjusted the balance of light groups then you can no longer subtract the specular as it contains the original light group balance, and vice versa.
But I suddenly thought, I wonder if somebody very clever has found a way of using both.
A = Original
B = LightGroups Adjustment
C = Beauty AOVs Ajustments
D = A == 0 ? 0 : B / A ( if A equal zero then zero, otherwise B divided by A )
R = C * D (C multiplied by D)
R is your Result
The order of B and C don’t really matter
In Flame you may need to write a Matchbox for this.
Not a full beauty rebuild, but…
If you want to use them to tweak the beauty / result you can just subtract them, tweak, and add back. You’d probably do this after your initial rebuild using whichever set you prefer. As long as you’re not clamping the different light balance you mentioned shouldn’t break the comp.
Or did you already try this?
I realize you may get away without a matchbox. The reason for the D expression is to avoid dividing by 0. You may be able to get around this by lifting the image ever so slightly by a very tiny amount, do the operation and the negating that change after… so regular Comp nodes my suffice. I’ll test tomorrow.